A more detailed explanation is needed to fully understand the paper ‘Radioactive concentrations in chemical fertilizers’ by Kim and Cho [1], published in the Journal of Radiation Protection and Research. This paper reports the measurement of radioactivity levels in five types of fertilizers, with basic data generated on their environmental impact and public radiation safety. According to the findings of this paper, 134Cs was detected in domestically distributed fertilizers at levels ranging from approximately 34.43 Bq/kg to 94.76 Bq/kg, whereas 137Cs was detected at levels ranging from 2.21 Bq/kg to 5.74 Bq/kg; 40K was detected at levels ranging from 347 Bq/kg to 70,007 Bq/kg.
However, these results appear to conflict somewhat with previous studies. The detection of 134Cs and 137Cs in domestic soil is covered in the paper titled ‘134Cs and 137Cs radioactivity in soil and moss samples of Jeju island after Fukushima nuclear reactor accident’ [2]. The radioactivity levels in the soil of Jeju island were measured to detect the 134Cs and 137Cs if originating from the Fukushima accident, observing 134Cs of up to 17 Bq/kg and 137Cs of up to 109 Bq/kg. Given that 134Cs has a short half-life of approximately 2.1 years, the 134Cs found in fertilizers cannot be attributed to the Fukushima accident. In addition, the ratio of 134Cs to 137Cs in the soil of Jeju island was reported to be 0.3, which differs from the ratio of Cs in fertilizers.
According to National Council on Radiation Protection and Measurements (NCRP) Report No. 154, approximately 90% of 137Cs originates from nuclear testing, 6% from the Chernobyl accident, and 4% from nuclear fuel reprocessing facilities [3]. Therefore, the presence of Cs in fertilizers may indicate previously undetected leaks of other radioactive substances. Furthermore, maximum activity concentration of 40K is 30.6 Bq/g in accordance with International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) SRS-49 due to the natural abundance of 40K in the environment [4]. But this paper shows 70 Bq/g in the phosphoric acid. Therefore, a more detailed examination should be conducted regarding the results of the paper, especially concerning the origin of the detected radionuclides and their potential implications.
Article InformationConflict of Interest Jiseok Kim is an editorial board member of the journal. But he was not involved in the peer reviewer selection, evaluation, or decision process of this article. No other potential conflicts of interest relevant to this article were reported. Ethical Statement This article does not contain any studies with human participants or animals performed by any of the authors. References1. Kim GH, Cho JH. Radioactive concentrations in chemical fertilizers. J Radiat Prot Res. 2022;47(4):195-203.
![]() 2. Park KH, Kang TW, Kim WJ, Park JW.
134Cs and 137Cs radioactivity in soil and moss samples of Jeju Island after Fukushima nuclear reactor accident. Appl Radiat Isot. 2013;81:379-382.
![]() ![]() 3. National Council on Radiation Protection and Measurements. NCRP Report no 154: Cesium-137 in the environment: radioecology and approaches to assessment and management. NCRP. 2006.
4. International Atomic Energy Agency. Safety reports series. No 49: Assessing the need for radiation protection measures in work involving minerals and raw materials. IAEA. 2006.
|
|